Wednesday, May 29, 2013
Is 2013 a make or break year for Matthew Stafford?
Keep Reading
Friday, May 24, 2013
Friday, January 20, 2012
2009 St. Louis Rams NFL draft review: Three years later

When we see teams pick at the top of the draft in many successive years, we automatically know that they have not done a great job making draft picks. In 2009 the Rams picked second, in 2010 first, 2011 14th, and they will have the second overall selection in the coming 2012 draft. That seems to be a strong indicator that there are missing the boat on a lot of draft picks.
Their first pick in 2009 was OT Jason Smith. It looks like he will be a salary cap casualty this off-season as his salary far outweighs his production on the field. He seems to not have a strong passion for the game, and that is a big issue. The future of the Rams rests in keeping QB Sam Bradford on his feet and if Smith cannot do that (in justifiable terms to his salary) then it may simply be time to move on for this team.
Now in the second round the Rams hit a home run in 2009. With the 35th overall pick they got MLB James Laurinitis out of
The news gets worse for this team as none of their picks past round four remain on the roster. That is seven draft picks for one impactful starter, one guy with no passion and a backup DT taken in round four. The simple fact here is the St. Louis Rams must do better in finding talent in the NFL draft. The final grade for this draft comes in at a C+ since Laurinitis is such an impactful player.
Related Links:
- St. Louis Rams War Room
- Rams news and notes
- Joshua Lobdell.com
Thursday, January 19, 2012
Detroit Lions 2009 NFL draft in review: three years out

The 2009 NFL draft will always hold a special place for me because it was the first draft I covered professionally, and it was were the rebirth of my team the Detroit Lions began. General Manager Martin Mayhew fleeced the Dallas Cowboys for a first round pick 20th overall and he began to rebuild a team that was not far removed from a 0-16 campaign. The Lions scored big in this draft and with that let us begin our final look at the NFL draft of 2009.
With the first pick overall the Lions selected QB Matthew Stafford out of
With the 20th overall pick picked up from the Cowboys in the Roy Williams trade. Mayhew took TE Brandon Pettigrew out of
With the 33rd overall pick in the second round the Lions picked up Safety Louis Delmas and he has become a fixture in the Lions secondary. For the record that is three impact starters with their first three picks, and that will be the legacy of this draft for Mayhew and the Lions.
Of course there was a miss in here. In the third round they selected WR Derrick Williams. We understand the team needs to have more at wide out than Calvin Johnson but Williams was a clear miss. So far the only miss in this draft class for the Lions of any consequence. They also landed DT Sammie Lee Hill and RB Aaron Brown who also contributed some.
In the end this draft will be remembered as the birthplace of the Lions rebuild plan. After three season and securing three impact starters we have to give it a final grade of an A.
Related Links:
Thursday, December 1, 2011
Week 13 NFL picks
So after getting my but kicked on Thanksgiving Day, I rebounded to go 12-4 in Week 12. Not to bad but I want more. I want to do better. I am looking for the perfect week. With that siad let us get started with the week 13 picks:Saturday, November 26, 2011
The Rest of the Week 12 NFL picks
Ok, ok I got roughed up a bit on Turkey Day, going just 1-2 but I am looking to rebound a bit with the games on Sunday and Monday. With that let's have at it:Wednesday, November 23, 2011
Thanksgiving Day Picks
So we have the usual trio of games on Thanksgiving. The Detroit Lions and Dallas Cowboys are at home, and the Baltimore Ravens get to host the one loss San Francisco 49ers. All three games are must watch TV, and my wife is super pissed that I will be spending the Holiday parked in my man cave watching all the great NFL action. Thursday, November 17, 2011
Week eleven NFL picks
Allrighty then, last week your truly went 10-6. Not terribly bad, but not where I would like to be. By the way, Thursday Night football is one of the best things of the fall, and with that said let us get to it:Thursday, November 10, 2011
Week Ten NFL Picks
Allrighty then, the first week of Thursday Night football and that means we get some football a little early. With that said let us get to my week ten NFL picks:Sunday, November 6, 2011
Is is time for the Cleveland Browns to move on from Peyton Hillis?

This is a very perplexing question. The Cleveland Browns have taken a big step back from what they were a year ago, especially given their offensive struggles so far in 2012. A large part of the blame rest on Head Coach Pat Shurmur and his decision to take on the role of offensive coordinator. A large piece of blames rests with QB Colt McCoy and his struggles and with the WR corps and their struggles. However, a large part of the blame is the diva like behavior of RB Peyton Hillis.
Peyton had a break out year in 2010, rushing from 1,177 yards. It earned him a spot the 2012 Madden cover. What has followed is a pretty poor showing for a professional athlete. He is in a contract year, and took some bad advice from his agent and sat out a game against the Miami Dolphins when many feel he should have played. He has a nagging injury and skipped some treatment to go get married. He took time to throw footballs off the crossbar in
Profootballtalk.com cites Mary Kay Cabot of the Cleveland Plain Dealer that the team is prepared to let Hillis go after the year and test free agency. There, his one great season, added to his diva act of 2012 is not going to get him the big contract he apparently wants.
It seems pretty clear that the Browns will have to move on from him. A young team, in the midst of a rebuild plan, cannot allow one player to so disrupt things. A message has to be sent that this type of behavior will not be accepted by this organization. Since there does not seem to be a veteran in the locker room that can send that message, General Manger Mike Holmgren will have to do it by sending Hillis on his way. To their credit, some Browns' veterans did have an intervention with the RB, and we will have to wait and see what effect that has.
The defense is pretty good, but their young QB is struggling, and the best friend of a struggling QB is a great running game. That is something fellow RB Montario Hardesty cannot do alone. This team needs Hillis to be the guy he was, and if he cannot be that, they need to move for the good of the team.
Related Links:
Saturday, November 5, 2011
Week Nine NFL Picks
So my record for the year (at least on this site) is 8-5. We are certainly looking to do better than that in week nine. With that said let's have at it. Wednesday, November 2, 2011
For Week Eight 8-5

So for the 13 games of the NFL in week eight I went 8-5. Not really great but not very terrible either.
For the record, I got the Baltimore Ravens, Houston Texans, New York Giants, Tennessee Titans, Buffalo Bills, Detroit Lions,
Where I went wrong was The Minnesota Vikings beating the Carolina Panthers and Cam Newton in
All in all 8-5 is not where I want to be in any week. 62% winning percentage is pretty good, even if I were a gambling degenerate and was getting down on all of these games. However, I always strive to do a little better, hopefully week nine brings my average way up.
Thursday, October 27, 2011
Week Eight NFL picks

So I get to move another one of my regular NFL columns to a new site. Since I am no longer working for that other site we will be starting fresh with the games on week number eight. Here is what I think about the week eight NFL games.
1.
The Ravens lost to the Jacksonville Jaguars last Monday night, and they will be looking to make a statement. They play very well at home. The best cure for a passing game that hasn't performed all that well is a game against the Cardinals. I got the Ravens winning this one convincingly.
2.
At this point, I would not pick the Vikings to beat a squad of girls or a flag football contest. They suck out loud and have never one a game in
3.
Yes, the Jaguars won on Monday night. However, they are still a bad team. The Texans need this game more and are the home team. Not to mention they have RB Arian Foster. I got the Texans in this one in a loss that will put Jack Del Rio's but on the hot seat.
4.
The Dolphins are a bad football team and the suck for luck controversy is sure to continue. They have no reason to win this game and if they were at home, I would be picking them to lose big. As it stands, I cannot see the Dolphins scoring more than 10 points and that will not get it done against the Giants.
5.
The Rams are terrible defensively and the Saints have a high-powered offense. For me that means the Saints blow out the Rams at home.
6.
Two very bad offenses, but the Colts have a bigger reason to lose this game so the can continue to “suck for Luck”. I will not be watching this game and it could be another crappy 6-3 game. I got the Titans in this one but a little bit.
7.
Normally when the Bills play in
8.
This is a tough one. The Lions are 3-0 on the road, but have lost two straight. The Broncos have Tim Tebow who is really good for one drive a game. Tebow's mobility is a problem for the Lions but I think the y get their season back on track with a fourth road win.
9. New England Patriots at
This is a simple one Tom Brady owns the Pittsburgh Steelers even when they have a legit dominating defense. I got the Pats by a bunch in this one.
10.
The
11.
I am not a believer in the Browns, and think they have large problems. The 49ers are coming off a bye and will not play down to them. It will be on the
12.
This is a tough one. I am not a big believer in either of these teams. The Eagles can gain a lot of yards, but they turn the ball over a lot.
13.
If this game were anywhere else, I would stick with the Chargers. However, the Chiefs run the ball well even without Jamal Charles. The Chargers have issues in run defense and added to the noise of Arrowhead Stadium I think the Chiefs win a close one.
Wednesday, October 26, 2011
Can the UFL survive once again?

Over the pat year, I have written a number of posts declaring the UFL either dead or on its deathbed. Some how this little league that could finds a way to come back, despite reports all over the web that they have failed to pay their bills and even some of their employees. Now I find in posts on profootballtalk.com and the UFL league site that the UFL owners remain committed and will return in 2012.
That seems pretty unreasonable since all this league has done since its inception is lose money, and blunder there way through three seasons. When the pulled the plug on the 2011 season halfway through that looked to be the final deathblow. Now it appears the UFL is willing not only to come back, but also to switch to a spring schedule where they could actually make some head way.
The thing they have going for them is the on the field product is good. It is good football and people will flock to good football especially in the spring. They have identified several good markets for themselves and if they keep on working that, they could very well survive and even thrive.
Of course, the other side of this coin is NFL Commish Roger Goodell told the press in
Of course, the NFL would have to learn the mistakes of NFL Europa. First and foremost, they would have to make a rule that every member of a team’s practice squad must play in this league. It will not work having each team send one player. NFL Europe helped the NFL develop a number of quality players and a spring based UFL developmental league could very well do the same.
Of course, to accommodate all those practice squad players, and all of the not quite ready for the NFL players coming out of college the UFL would have to field more than four teams. It seems that eight teams would be the minimum number needed to make something like this viable. That of course would mean the UFL would have to find at least four more markets where their teams could thrive. They seem very interested in
The thing to remember here is Goodell wants a player development league that is not commercial, that is in one location ala the NFL Scouting Combine and annual Senior Bowl in
Related Links:
Tuesday, October 25, 2011
What is wrong with the Cleveland Browns?

The Cleveland Browns are probably the worst 3-3 team I have ever seen in twenty plus years of watching NFL football and now six writing about it. They are one of the few teams I have seen play live in their own building this year (thanks to my membership in a Browns Backer club). The question has got to be what is wrong with this team, if anything?
I think the Browns have a number of problems. The offense is not very good, and is adapting to a new offense. New Head Coach Pat Shurmur has changed a lot of things and I am not a big believer in the Head Coach taking on the offensive coordinator job as well. It seems evident that Shurmur is overmatched as an offensive play caller. They rank 27th in points scored averaging just 16.2 points per game. They are averaging over 300 yards of total offense a game, but that has them ranked just 23rd. They rank 22nd in passing yards per game and just 29th in rushing yards.
Of course the bigger problem here may be the attitude of RB Peyton Hillis. I truly believe, despite what many of my Browns Backer friend think (granted they have rooted for this team far longer than I have), that Hillis has let his 2010 success and his presence on the Madden Cover to go to his head. I also happen to think his agent is not doing him nay favors, and that this situation has severely distracted a pretty young locker room. That is all bad.
Beyond the questions about Colt McCoy who is having a pretty forgettable sophomore campaign. He has 14 passing TD's but has also thrown 13 picks. I really think that this team has a wide receiver problem. Greg Little and Joshua Cribbs have talent, but they do not have a wide out who can stretch the field. Little is averaging less than 10 yards a completion and looks to be an ok piece, but this is an offense that still needs a legit deep threat. Cribbs feels like more of a game changer than a legit wide out talent and is only averaging 12.8 yards per catch. Mohamed Massaquuoi drops a lot of passes put is averaging 13.3 yards per catch. However it does not feel like enough.
Sure, some of those numbers may be due to McCoy's arm. At this point this team and its fans have to question everything. However, it does not look like they go down the field enough, and the problems with Hillis are disturbing the flow of the running attack. I truly believe that the offense is the problem here.
The defense, under Dick Jauron, is fifth in total average yards allowed at 291 per game. They are second in passing yard allowed where they give up just 172 yards through the air on average. However they are 19th in rush defense and that speaks to a weaker LB corps or problems along the Defensive Line. That could be explained away by the switch to the 4-3 scheme and the fact that two rookies are starting on the D line.
We see this a lot, teams that look pretty good one year taking a big step back the next. We have also seen new Head Coaches come to teams, and those rosters take a little bit of time to get use to new systems and new expectations. In the end that is what I see when I look at the 2011 Cleveland Browns.
Before I made a final decision on Colt McCoy I would like to see this team get him some legit talent in the WR corps and see if that makes the difference. Of course the Browns have not had a ton of luck in developing young QB's recently.
Related Links:
Tuesday, October 18, 2011
The Oakland Raiders trade for Carson Palmer

So The Oakland Raiders, motivated by an injury to QB Jason Campbell, traded a 2012 first round pick and a 2013 second round pick to the Cincinnati Bengals for QB Carson Palmer. That 2013 pick could become a first round pick if the Raiders win a divisional round playoff game. For those keeping score at home that means the Raiders now have a 2012 first round, 2012 third round, 2012 fourth round, and a 2013 second round pick tied up in the three QB's on their roster.
Normally I would not be so harsh on them, but that seems like an incredible investment in QB's with no real proof that any of these decisions are going to work out. They gave up a fourth round pick in next year's draft for Jason Campbell. He has performed pretty well, and an injury is hard to avoid. However, with Palmer and Pryor on the roster he will not be back in
However, they have already used a 2012 third round pick for Terrell Pryor. Now with Palmer on the roster Pryor becomes the backup. A fourth round pick by itself is not a terrible price to pay for a good backup, but we do not know if he will be a good backup yet. Having Palmer on the roster would seem to limit the amount of snaps he can take, as Palmer will have to be rushed through his learning of the Raider offense. Granted Kyle Boller is not the answer and some sort of move had to be made.
We could even excuse the trading of a first round pick for Palmer if he can come in and be effective, but that is hardly a guarantee. The point here is none of these moves by themselves should be cause to waive a red flag, but with all the Raiders trades, they now have no picks in the 2012 NFL draft until round five. For a relatively good team that looks to be close to doing something special that could severely set this team back in the future. Of course, it could also put them over the top.
Let us not forget that the Raiders did not trade for the Palmer we saw in 2005 and 2006. No, they traded for a 31-year-old guy who has not looked all that great over the last two years. Over the past two seasons, he has thrown 47 TD's and 33 picks. Those are not great numbers. His QB rating has not been above 85.0 in those years, and there are very real questions about his arm strength.
The better news here is in both of those years he threw for more than 3,000 yards and completed more than 60% of his passes. If he can do that for the Raiders than they may end looking all right. However, while the Raiders are certainly a good team I do not know if going all in (in terms of draft picks) on a trio of QB's for team that is as far away as this team feels is a great policy.
Of course, I could be wrong and Palmer and Pryor could ignite the Raiders to a strong post-season run, which of course would cost the team a first round pick in 2013. We will have to wait and see on this one.
Related Links:
Tuesday, August 30, 2011
What is going on with the Chicago Bears?
It has been a pretty embarrassing year for the Chicago Bears. It started last April when the Bears front office staff brought the entire NFL draft to a grinding halt. It continued after the lockout ended when the front office made several questionable personnel decisions. Then of course, there was the embarrassment of the Solider Field turf, and I haven't even gotten to the Chester Tailor incident. Someone is obviously asleep at the wheel, and the Bears reputation not only with its fans and players has being affected, but its standing with the 31 other NFL teams is certainly being affected.
Let us start with the incident at the NFL draft. The Baltimore Ravens believe, and have said publicly, that the Bears duped them on purpose. They claim that the Bears purposely misled them and the rest of the NFL by not turning in a trade request within the allotted time. If that is true, the Bears are guilty of fraud and there is no other way to say that. NFL clubs should not conduct themselves in this way (if it is true of course).
That of course brings me to the handling of longtime Center Olin Kreutz. This was a very popular player in the locker room, and teams always have to treat those kinds of players a tad differently. It looks like the Bears gave him a take it or leave it offer, with an hour deadline no less. Granted some of that is rumor, but Kreutz did what we expected him too, and the Bears told him not to let the door hit him in he ass on the way out. This has upset many within that locker room.
We can sort of but the turf problem aside, but I find it curios that no one at the Bears of Solider Field looked out their office windows and saw a potential problem, nor took action to deal with it. Then again, if he team cannot even decide who is cut and who isn't, then maybe we have the why to behind how something like this could happen.
The Bears have all the problems other NFL teams have. They have made some mistakes in the draft, taken flyers on guys that were utterly worthless, and sure, other NFL teams alienate their players and fans too. However, it is the Bears turn to look a little foolish and foolish is what they appear to be right now.
Related Links:
• Chicago Bears news and notes
• Joshua Lobdell.com
